Wynonna Judd performed a new song, “Girl Who Could Sing,” Oct. 8 on TODAY, and it certainly resonated with Carson Daly.
The track, from her first new album in 10 years, “The Hard Truth,” is about how she never met her biological father.
“I didn’t find out he was my real father until I was 30. So this is a very heavy song,” she said before playing it.
After wrapping up, Carson was visibly moved.
“Wow, you’re getting me there, man,” he said.
“My goodness,” she said.
“Yeah, I didn’t know my biological father, so that song, like every lyric of that hits home,” he said.
Carson’s biological father, Jim Daly, died of bladder cancer in 1979 when Carson was 5.
During the pandemic in 2020, he and his older sister, Quinn, re-created a photo of him mixing a drink in the 1970s while wearing a UCLA zip-up.
“I feel like I time traveled back to like 1978 for a second there and entered the personal space of my father, and I’m grateful for that,” Carson said on TODAY at the time.
“I have so few shared experiences with him, it’s like a powerful moment,” he said.
For Carson, the performance and song’s premise struck a chord.
“For me it was just cool putting on the UCLA sweatshirt because I have so few things that connect me to my biological father,’’ he said. “To be able to re-create that photo was really cool. That dichotomy I see in Dad’s face when I look at that picture. I don’t know if he’s running from fear or head into it.”
A few years after his father died, Carson’s mother, Patti, married Richard Caruso, whom Carson called “Pops.” The couple died five weeks apart in 2017 from unrelated ailments. Carson had a strong relationship with Caruso and mourned his death.
“Pops passed away today with absolute dignity & pride. The greatest man we ever knew. Our hero,” he wrote on Instagram.
“He exemplified great faith, loyalty to family & hard work. He provided us all with so much. We’re grateful. His legacy lives on in all of us & anyone who had the pleasure of meeting him. He’s reunited with mom now.”
Judd has opened up about how the man she believed to be her father, Michael Ciminella, was not actually her dad. Her biological father was man named Charles Jordan. He dated her mother, Naomi, when they were teenagers.
“She was very much in love with him, and they were just too young … she got pregnant, and that’s that,” Judd told People last month. “Back in 1963 that just didn’t happen without there being consequences that were intense.”
It was a development she addressed in “Girl Who Could Sing.”
“I was 30 years old when I learned the truth, that the man I called ‘Dad’ my entire life, was not my biological father,” she said in a statement released along with the song.
“It changed everything I thought I knew about who I was. By the time I was ready to meet him, he was gone. I never got to hear his voice, look him in the eyes, or ask him why. I’ll carry those unanswered questions with me for the rest of my life. ‘Was I ever really your daughter, or just a girl who could sing?’ is the question that hurts the most — because I’ll never get to hear his answer. What do you do with the questions you’ll never have answers to? My answer is simple … I sing about it.”