Trump administration, Congress move to cut off transgender care for children

Trump administration, Congress move to cut off transgender care for children


The Trump administration and House Republicans advanced measures this week to end gender-affirming care for transgender children and some young adults, drawing outrage and resistance from LGBTQ+ advocacy organizations, families with transgender kids, medical providers and some of Californiaโ€™s liberal leaders.

The latest efforts โ€” which seek to ban such care nationwide, strip funding from hospitals that provide it and punish doctors and parents who perform or support it โ€” follow earlier executive orders from President Trump and work by the Justice Department to rein in such care.

Many hospitals, including in California, have already curtailed such care or shuttered their gender-affirming care programs as a result.

Abigail Jones, a 17-year-old transgender activist from Riverside, called the moves โ€œridiculousโ€ and dangerous, as such care โ€œsaves lives.โ€

She also called them a purely political act by Republicans intent on making transgender people into a โ€œmonsterโ€ to rally their base against, and one that is โ€œgoing to backfire on them because theyโ€™re not focusing on what the people want,โ€ such as affordability and lower healthcare costs.

On Wednesday, the House passed a sweeping ban on gender-affirming care for youth that was put forward by Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), largely along party lines.

The bill โ€” which faces a tougher road in the U.S. Senate โ€” bars already rare gender-affirming surgeries but also more common treatments such as hormone therapies and puberty blockers for anyone under 18. It also calls for the criminal prosecution of doctors and other healthcare workers who provide such care, and for penalties for parents who facilitate or consent to it being performed on their children.

โ€œChildren are not old enough to vote, drive, or get a tattoo and they are certainly not old enough to be chemically castrated or permanently mutilated!!!โ€ Greene posted on X.

โ€œThe tide is turning and Iโ€™m so grateful that congress is taking measurable steps to end this practice that destroyed my childhood,โ€ posted Chloe Cole, a prominent โ€œdetransitionerโ€ who campaigns against gender-affirming care for children, which she received and now regrets.

Queer rights groups denounced the measure as a dangerous threat to medical providers and parents, and one that mischaracterizes legitimate care backed by major U.S. medical associations. They also called it a threat to LGBTQ+ rights more broadly.

โ€œShould this bill become law, doctors could face the threat of prison simply for doing their jobs and providing the care they were trained to deliver. Parents could be criminalized and even imprisoned for supporting their children and ensuring they receive prescribed medication,โ€ said Kelley Robinson, president of the Human Rights Campaign, one of the nationโ€™s leading LGBTQ+ rights groups.

On Thursday, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services announced that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services are proposing new rules that would ban such care by medical providers that participate in its programs โ€” which includes nearly all U.S. hospitals. The health department said the move is โ€œdesigned to ensure that the U.S. government will not be in business with organizations that intentionally or unintentionally inflict permanent harm on children.โ€

The department said officials will propose additional rules to prohibit Medicaid or federal Childrenโ€™s Health Insurance Program funding from being used for gender-affirming care for children or for young adults under the age of 19, and that its Office of Civil Rights would be proposing a rule to exclude gender dysphoria as a covered disability.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration, meanwhile, issued warning letters to manufacturers of certain medical devices, including breast binders, that marketing their products to transgender youth is illegal.

โ€œUnder my leadership, and answering President Trumpโ€™s call to action, the federal government will do everything in its power to stop unsafe, irreversible practices that put our children at risk,โ€ Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said in a statement. โ€œOur children deserve better โ€” and we are delivering on that promise.โ€

The proposed rule changes are subject to public comment, and the Human Rights Campaign and other LGBTQ+ organizations, including the Los Angeles LGBT Center, urged their supporters to voice their opposition.

Joe Hollendoner, the centerโ€™s chief executive, said the proposed changes โ€œcruelly target transgender youthโ€ and will โ€œdestabilize safety-net hospitalsโ€ and other critical care providers.

โ€œHospitals should never be forced to choose between providing lifesaving care to transgender young people and delivering critical services like cancer treatment to other patients,โ€ Hollendoner said. โ€œYet this is exactly the division and harm these rules are designed to create.โ€

Hollendoner noted that California hospitals such as Childrenโ€™s Hospital Los Angeles have already curtailed their gender-affirming services in the face of earlier threats from the Trump administration, and thousands of transgender youth have already lost access to care.

Gov. Gavin Newsom issued a statement contrasting the Trump administrationโ€™s moves with Californiaโ€™s new partnership with The Trevor Project, to improve training for the stateโ€™s 988 crisis and suicide hotline for vulnerable youth, including LGBTQ+ kids at disproportionately high risk of suicide and mental health issues.

โ€œAs the Trump administration abandons the well-being of LGBTQ youth, California is putting more resources toward providing vulnerable kids with the mental health support they deserve,โ€ Newsom said.

California Atty. Gen. Rob Bontaโ€™s office is already suing the Trump administration for its efforts to curtail gender-affirming care and target providers of such care in California, where it is protected and supported by state law. His office has also resisted Trump administration efforts to roll back other transgender rights, including in youth sports.

On Thursday, Bonta said the proposed rules were โ€œthe Trump Administrationโ€™s latest attempt to strip Americans of the care they need to live as their authentic selves.โ€ He also said they are โ€œunlawful,โ€ and that his office will fight them.

โ€œIf the Trump Administration puts forth final rules similar to these proposals, we stand ready to use every tool in our toolbox to prevent them from ever going into effect,โ€ Bonta said โ€” adding that โ€œmedically necessary gender-affirming care remains protected by California law.โ€

Arne Johnson, a Bay Area father of a transgender child who helps run a group of similar families called Rainbow Families Action, said there has been โ€œa lot of hate spewedโ€ toward them in recent days, but they are focused on fighting back โ€” and asking hospital networks to โ€œnot panic and shut down careโ€ based on proposed rules that have not been finalized.

Johnson said Republicans and Trump administration officials are โ€œweirdly obsessedโ€ with transgender kidsโ€™ bodies, are โ€œbreaking the trust between us and our doctors,โ€ and are putting politics in between families and their healthcare providers in dangerous ways.

He said parents of transgender kids are โ€œused to being hurt and upset and sad and worried about their kids, and also doing everything in their power to make sure that nothing bad happens to them,โ€ and arenโ€™t about to stop fighting now.

But resisting such medical interference isnโ€™t just about gender-affirming care. Next it could be over vaccines being blocked for kids, he said โ€” which should get all parents upset and vocal.

โ€œIf our kids donโ€™t get care, theyโ€™re coming for your kids next,โ€ Johnson said. โ€œPretty soon all of us are going to be going into hospital rooms wondering whether that doctor across from us can be trusted to give our kid the best care โ€” or if their hands are going to be tied.โ€

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *